The Child Care Dilemma: Availability & Access
- The cost of child care for one infant at a child care center, where child care is provided in a facility outside a home, represented on average between 9 percent and 35 percent of the median household income for a family with children across the states in 2014. The picture was a bit better for family care centers, where the care setting is the child care pro- vider’s home—between 1.5 percent and 25 percent.1
- For a single parent with two children living at the federal poverty level, infant child care at a child care center would eat up at least a quarter of the family’s income of $19,073.2
- In many states, child care is more expensive than public university tuition. However, the financial burden of child care decreases as children get older.3
- States receive federal dollars from the Child Care Development Fund, or CCDF, administered by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services to provide financial relief for low-income families in the form of child care subsidies. While there are some parameters set by federal statute, states still have some control over eligibility requirements, including income.4
- Considering population estimates and program participation, among all U.S. children under age 5, between 1.15 percent and 7.5 percent were served by the CCDF subsidy program in the states; for children under 14, the proportion benefitting from the program’s subsidies range was 0.75 percent to4.3 percent of the population.5 To contrast, the poverty rate for U.S. children overall was between 11.5 and 32.2 percent, depending on state of residence.6 Families that do receive this grant may have a copay- ment, and if so, the average copayment for child care represented between 2.7 percent and 40.5 percent of family income depending on their state of residence in 2014.7
Availability of Child Care8
There is wide variance on the availability of child care from state to state. According to data published by Child Care Aware of America, if all the guardians of children under age 5 wanted to place their child in a child care center or family care center in 2014, for the 39 states and the District of Columbia reporting, there would not be enough spaces.9 Vermont had the highest ratio of child care slots to children under 5 at 80.8 percent. However, the total number of slots used in this formula included care for school-age children; likely in most states, the ratio of child care slots to children not yet in school was lower. The average ratio of child care slots to children across states in 2014 was approximately 51 percent. If all of those child care slots were for children under age 5, only half of them would have a space available to them in a child care center or family care center. Of the 39 states and District of Columbia reporting, 16 states and Washington, D.C., fell below that average. Utah had the lowest ratio of child care slots to children, where there were only 0.15 slots for every child under 5 years old.
Of the child care slots available in 38 of the 40 reporting jurisdictions in 2014, the majority of those slots were in child care centers. Only in Minnesota is the majority of slots available in family care centers, in which child care is provided out of the child care provider’s home. In Kansas, there isn’t a clear majority, with a fairly even split between the number of slots in child care centers and family care centers. In 12 states, more than a quarter of those jurisdictions reporting, slots in child care centers represented over 90 percent of what was available on the market in 2014.
The number of available slots is impacted by the num- ber of child care workers. Comparing the number of child care workers in 2014 in the states to the number of centers and family care homes, the ratio of workers to child care facilities ranged from 4.87 in Utah to less than one in Illinois, Louisiana, Minnesota, New Mexico and Vermont.10 On average, child care workers in 2014 made between $18,090 and $26,470 a year.11
Access to Child Care
What resources are states providing guardians needing child care to learn about what’s available in their area and how particular options compare? Guardians can search for child care providers online; states have elec- tronic provider search tools for families to peruse to find options for child care in their area, as mandated by law via the Child Care and Development Block Grant of 2014.12
There are many potential challenges to accessing care—finding a quality program is only one of several. For instance, families may struggle to find a provider that has space for their child and meets the family’s financial needs. Subsidies administered by state gov- ernments from the CCDF program are one of several options available to families to access early childhood education. Others include Head Start, Early Head Start and state pre-kindergarten programs, all of which are free of charge to families of the children they serve. Some of these programs have income-level eligibility requirements, while others do not.
Adding the number of children served by Head Start programs and CCDF subsidies together, the ratio of federally funded or federally subsidized early child- hood education programs comes into focus. Assuming no overlap in service utilization, the District of Colum- bia has the highest potential capacity in federally funded programs. In Washington, D.C., almost 20 percent of children under age 5 could have been in an early child- hood education setting covered by federal funding in 2014. In addition to Washington, D.C., 13 states had ratios of federally subsidized early childhood education programs to children under age 5 that were higher than 10 percent that year. Nevada had the lowest proportion of early childhood education program slots to children under 5 covered by federal dollars, followed by Utah and Maryland; all three states had ratios under 6 percent.
To provide access to quality, affordable early childhood education, some states have supplemented federally funded programs and offer state early childhood edu- cation options. In 2015, 42 states and the District of Columbia had some type of state-funded preschool program, and 33 of these programs had income requirements.13 For example, in Vermont, 84 percent of 4 year olds and 26 percent of 3 year olds enrolled in a state pre-kindergarten program in 2014.14 By law, all school districts in Vermont must provide pre-kindergarten for at least 10 hours per week for 35 weeks of the year; Vermont also has set quality standards for all pre-K operations.15
Waiting lists are also a challenge for many families. While information on the prevalence of long waiting times for preferred child care providers is mostly anecdotal, there is state-by-state data on waiting lists for child care assistance. According to a survey conducted by the National Women’s Law Center in 2015, 21 states used waiting lists for child care assistance subsidies.16 Of those that were able to report the number of chil- dren on waiting lists for child care assistance—some states had locally maintained waiting lists—the average number of children on a state waitlist was 10,725. Florida reported the longest waitlist, with 51,397 children wait- ing for child care assistance. The shortest lists were in New Mexico and Colorado, the former having a list of 126 children and the latter’s list having 45 entries.
What’s At Stake for Quality Care?
Research has shown that early childhood education is important to future success. The fourth brief in this series will explore how states are assessing and impacting the quality of early childhood education experience. Keys to quality programs include an experienced and educated workforce, standard met- rics measuring quality, and consumer transparency.
The fifth and final brief will bring these themes to- gether—what does all of this mean for families making decisions about guardian workforce participation? How are states addressing the question of child care?
Other briefs in this series:
- Affordability. How much does child care cost in each state, before and after subsidies?
- Availability and Access. How many slots are available per child in each state, and how can families find quality options?
- Quality. How are states managing certification requirements, assessing quality and developing the child care workforce?
- Implications for the Workforce. What are the economic costs of child care for families? We take a look at what the cost of child care could mean for parents in the workforce and the innovative ways states are tackling the issue in their communities.
1 Author’s analysis of U.S. Census ACS 2014 estimates and Child Care Aware 2015 State Fact Sheets, showing 2014 data. See “The Child Care Dilemma: Affordability” for more information and data set.
4 Minton, Sarah; Stevens, Kathryn; Blatt, Lorraine; and Durham, Christin of the Urban Institute. U.S. Department of Health & Human Services Administration for Children & Families Office of Planning, Research & Evaluation. The CCDF Policies Database Book of Tables: Key Cross-State Variations in CCDF Policies as of October 1, 2014, http://www.acf.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/opre/ccdf_policies_database_2.... October 2015.
5 Author’s analysis of: U.S. Census ACS 2014 Estimates; and U.S. Department of Health & Human Services Administration for Children & Families Office of Child Care. Characteristics of Families Served by Child Care and Development Fund
(CCDF) Based on Preliminary FY 2014 Data, http://www.acf.hhs.gov/occ/resource/characteristics-of-families-served-b....
October 22, 2015.
6 U.S. Census ACS 2014 Estimates.
7 U.S. Department of Health & Human Services Administration for Children & Families Office of Child Care. Characteristics of Families Served by Child Care and Development Fund (CCDF) Based on Preliminary FY 2014 Data, http://www.acf.hhs.gov/occ/resource/characteristics-of-families-served-b.... October 22, 2015.
8 All information on number of slots available comes from Child Care Aware of America’s 2015 State Fact Sheets, which represent 2014 access. http://www.usa.childcareaware.org/advocacypublicpolicy/resources/reports...statefactsheets/.
9 Author’s analysis of Child Care Aware Fact Sheets and the U.S. Census ACS 2014 estimates.
12 U.S. Department of Health & Human Services Administration for Children & Families Office of Child Care. “Child Care and Development Block Grant Act (CCDBG) of 2014: Plain Language Summary of Statutory Changes,” http://www.acf.hhs.gov/occ/resource/ccdbg-of-2014-plain-language-summary... changes. November 18, 2014.
13 National Institute for Early Education Research. “The State of Preschool 2015: State Preschool Yearbook Executive Overview,” http://nieer.org/sites/nieer/files/Executive%20Summary%202015.pdf. Pg 10.
14 Ibid. Pg 14.
15 National Institute for Early Education Research. “The State of Preschool 2015: State Preschool Yearbook, Vermont,” http://nieer.org/sites/nieer/files/Vermont_ 2015.pdf. 2015.
16 Schulman, Karen; Blank, Helen. National Women’s Law Center. “Building Blocks: State Child Care Assistance Policies 2015,” https://nwlc.org/wpcontent/uploads/2015/11/CC_RP_Building_Blocks_Assista.... Table 2: Waiting Lists for Child Care Assistance. Pg 26.